Tag Archives: sam bishoff

Matthew Barney and Jonathan Bepler’s ‘River of Fundament’ at New York City’s Masonic Hall and Discussion at Public Records

Matthew Barney and Jonathan Bepler’s River of Fundament took over Masonic Hall in New York City on November 14, produced by the New People’s Cinema Club as part of the Unsound Festival. This was only the second screening of River of Fundament in NYC since its 2014 premiere at Brooklyn Academy of Music. The eight-hour event included a full screening of the 330-minute operatic film, two intermissions with food (catered by White Castle!) and drinks, live music in the form of musical interjections by Jonathan Bepler and colleagues, a touching and elegiac introduction by Matthew Barney remembering departed cast and crew, and a continuous sense of excitement in the air. The atmosphere was more that of a live concert-cum-convocation than a film screening.

masonic hall new york city

By the time the doors opened to start the event, the line stretched around two corners of the city block. It was sold out with reportedly over 800 attendees. The choice of venue was appropriate, given the Masonic themes in 2002’s Cremaster 3, featuring the character of the Entered Apprentice portrayed by Barney. As a nod to Cremaster 3, for Barney’s portrayal of the Ka of Norman in River of Fundament, he wore a decrepit version of the same Entered Apprentice uniform. (Ditto Aimee Mullins‘s portrayal of Isis in River of Fundament echoing her Entered Novitiate in Cremaster 3.) Additionally, the Egyptological references throughout River of Fundament nicely befitted a Masonic setting. In addition to Barney and Bepler, members of the crew were also in attendance (e.g., cinematographer Peter Strietmann), as well as musicians from the film. I also saw Secondary‘s Raphael Xavier, among other notables—a real Who’s Who of the greater Barney universe.

The Grand Lodge Room was transformed into a theater, and between the stage and seats was a makeshift pit for the musicians to augment the score throughout the screening. Jonathan Bepler led and performed with the ensemble of Mick Barr, Sam Bishoff, Eric Hubel, and Megan Schubert (also of Redoubt). (Barr, Hubel, and Schubert also appear throughout the film.) The program began with a musical invocation of organ and ambulatory winds. After several minutes, over a live musical bed, Barney took the stage to read the names of late members of the cast and crew. After his solemn remembrance, the film began. The ensemble took to the pit and performed throughout much (but not all) of the film. Some parts were faint complements (e.g., dripping or sloshing water), and others were more interactive (e.g., additional instrumental or vocal resources to augment the existing score). The so-called interjections were tasteful, from subtle murmurations to cacophonous gestures. Much of River of Fundament‘s music emerges organically out of the diegetic sonic environment (e.g., instruments tuning up at the wake, bleeding radiators, etc.), so having a live element to complement what’s on the screen and in the speakers made for a rich sonic experience.

river of fundament at the grand lodge of masonic hall new york city

The live musical invocation before each act was related to the material in some way. The whistles and other winds plus organ before the first act were reminiscent of some of the wake’s more worldly characteristics before the spirits begin to fully replace the wake guests. The second act’s invocation included strings and voice, before both the metalin-backed vocal aria at the beginning of KHU (the live performance in Detroit) as well as some of the more frenzied transitional wake passages. And the low horns before Act III were a nod to those used in BA (the live NYC performance).

As mentioned above, the audience’s energy and interest throughout the afternoon and evening were palpable. From what I could tell through my own conversations and what I heard from others, most attendees hadn’t seen the film before but were actively interested, and the audience broke into applause after each act, with many staying through the most of the credits. The difference between Saturday and my first viewing experience couldn’t have been more stark. I remember there being ~75 people at the 2016 screening I attended at the Cleveland Institute of Art, and there was heavy attrition throughout. There were a handful of us that lasted the duration, and the room felt utterly deflated. (I felt completely out of place having had a nearly transcendent experience.) While the audience reduced some after each act last weekend, most of the crowd stayed until the end, enthusiastically.

river of fundament in the grand lodge at masonic hall in new york city

River of Fundament was even better this second viewing. I have many thoughts on that specifically, though I’ll save those for a separate post. (My initial take from a decade ago holds up.) Suffice it to say, after ruminating on the film in my mind’s eye and ear for a decade, it was wild—and cathartic—seeing it again.

The next day featured a discussion with Matthew Barney and Jonathan Bepler led by ARTnews and Art in America executive editor Andy Battaglia. The talk, part of the Durations Festival, was held in an intimate space at Brooklyn’s Public Records. I was looking forward to Mr. Battaglia’s moderation, as he’s written wonderfully about Barney in the past, including about River of Fundament specifically. He delivered, dealing with the film as an operatic work, which is to say a marriage of music and drama. (Finally, someone did it!) He centered both the sonic and the visual elements, and the resulting discussion and anecdotes from Barney and Bepler were informative and compelling.

andy battaglia matthew barney and jonathan bepler in conversation at public records in brooklyn

Given my keen interest, I’ve watched, read, and listened to the various interviews with Barney alone or Barney with Bepler over the years, and many of the interviews fall into a couple of traps: a narrow focus on the visual at the expense—and nearly omission of—the sonic; and/or an attempt to engage Barney on whether it’s a Gesamtkunstwerk1, which Barney has repeatedly rejected. I was relieved it wasn’t uttered once. The discussion ran the gamut from their work on River of Fundament specifically to their collaboration broadly. Their iterative process is as much about reacting to one another’s ideas through their own respective medium as it is any sort of collective creation. And, though I won’t name names, it was a treat to hear some of the behind-the-scenes anecdotes.

This was my fifth and favorite Barney experience to date. From stumbling upon the River of Fundament exhibit at Munich’s Haus der Kunst in 2014, to later trekking to Cleveland for the film in 2016, Redoubt at Yale in 2019, Secondary at Barney’s Long Island City studio in 2023, to this weekend in NYC, it’s been a fascinating journey. I’m already looking forward to the next installment.

[Previous Matthew Barney-related posts are here.]

  1. Yes, I’m a Wagnerian and have used the term when discussing Barney’s work, but it seems to be the one operatic term that people deploy when trying to tackle this work, with little else beyond that. Beyond the G-word, I thought I heard a Wagnerian reference in Redoubt which has stayed with me. Alas, I didn’t ask Bepler about it when I had the chance. ↩︎